Soft Market
Condo developer stops work, citing suddenly softer market
By Henry J. Holcomb
Inquirer Staff Writer
Latest stories on the housing market
A major condominium developer put plans for his 30-story Marina View Towers on hold yesterday, complaining that a softening market has made it hard to hold prices high enough to cover rising construction costs.
"It has suddenly become a buyers' market," said developer Louis A. Cicalese.
Site preparation had started for the $119 million building next to the Benjamin Franklin Bridge overlooking the Delaware River.
The decision is the strongest sign yet that the Center City residential condominium market, red-hot for two years, has cooled.
While two major developers are pressing ahead, others are becoming cautious and complaining that media coverage of whether the condo market is in a boom or a bubble is causing the problem.
The demographic groups - young professionals and empty nesters - who are looking for shorter commutes and an urban lifestyle are destined to be strong for years, brokers and developers say.
"We're not discouraged. We still plan to build it, and we think it is going to be the best building in the city," Cicalese said.
Cicalese is a Philadelphia native who made a lot of money in California real estate before moving to Ottsville, Bucks County. He and his partners own three prime condo sites on the waterfront. He said yesterday that they still planned to build on all three.
Marina View, pictured on billboards along traffic-clogged expressways into the city, had attracted reservations for 60 of its 197 units. All deposits will be refunded, Cicalese said. Prices for the condos ranged from $300,000 for the smallest one-bedroom unit, about 800 square feet, to $2 million for the larger units.
His other sites are Pier 34 in South Philadelphia, where the Marina View sales office is located, and Pier 40, just north of Waterfront Square, a five-building gated community under construction near the foot of Spring Garden Street.
Other developers acknowledged that the market was softening, but said they were pressing ahead.
Hal Wheeler, developer of the 33-story Ten Rittenhouse Square, at 18th and Walnut Streets, said 25 truckloads of steel would arrive at his site Sept. 12. Tom Scannapieco has opened a sales office next to his 31-story ultra-upscale tower at 1701 Rittenhouse Square St., between Locust and Spruce Streets. He said construction would start next spring.
But Tim Mahoney said yesterday he was looking for ways to "take some of the risks out" of a 57-story condo skyscraper that he and partner Brook J. Lenfest have planned at 15th and Chestnut Streets.
Mahoney and Lenfest put the project, which has cleared all government hurdles, up for sale in June, when the market was hot and brokers were predicting it would fetch $60 million.
Yesterday, Mahoney said he was exploring new ways to build the tower himself, adding that it is still on the market, but that "I don't think we're going to get a number that appeals to us."
The DePaul Group of Blue Bell, meanwhile, said in a recent interview it would wait until January to decide when to build a second luxury condominium tower next to its "Residences at Dockside" just south of Penn's Landing at 717 S. Columbus Blvd.
Mahoney grumbled that media coverage pondering whether the boom would soon cool has, at least for now, produced a "self-fulfilling prophecy."
Joanne Davidow, manager of the Rittenhouse Square office of the Prudential Fox & Roach real estate firm, said "the demand is still there" but the market has quickly changed.
"One minute we're amazingly busy, then there were a lot of articles asking, 'Is this a boom or bubble?' I'm not surprised some are taking a step back... to see if prices will go down," Davidow said.
Davidow and others predicted that the pause would be brief. "Nothing else has happened. I don't see interest rates going up significantly. My thought is if you are an older baby boomer and you want to do something, how long are you going to wait?" Davidow said. "There is an awful lot of demand out there."
But for now, Marina View developer Cicalese said, demand has gone down while "concrete and drywall costs are going up dramatically, and copper has gone through the roof." At times like these, he said, "the fact is you need to be careful."
Contact staff writer Henry J. Holcomb at 215-854-2614 or hholcomb@phillynews.com
